The official student newspaper of Walter Johnson High School

The Pitch

The official student newspaper of Walter Johnson High School

The Pitch

The official student newspaper of Walter Johnson High School

The Pitch

Transgender issues become federal with historic Supreme Court case

Transgender+issues+become+federal+with+historic+Supreme+Court+case

In late October of 2016, the Supreme Court finally agreed to review a case on the right of transgender students to use the communal restroom of their gender identity.

Transgender people have been fighting for equality for much of American history, but the transgender rights movement has only recently become well-known. Recent events like Caitlyn Jenner’s transition and the discriminatory HB2 “bathroom bill” in North Carolina have brought the movement to the forefront of public attention.

One of the most debated issues is whether or not trans people, especially trans students, should be allowed to use the correct restroom or locker room for their gender. Many schools across the country are prohibiting trans students from using the restroom of their gender,and are either forcing the students to use a segregated private restroom or making them use the restroom of their assigned sex.

The idea that trans people should be allowed to use the restroom that matches their gender should not be up for question. Studies show that it does not increase the risk of sexual or physical violence; in fact, trans people are more at risk of being attacked or harassed in the bathroom of their assigned sex. This policy does not “let boys into the girls’ facilities”. Trans girls are girls, and trans boys are boys, and they should all be allowed to use the correct restrooms. Forcing them to use wrong or segregated restrooms can negatively impact their mental health and can subject them to bullying or violence from peers.

Story continues below advertisement

This struggle for the basic right to access public accommodations without emotional injury has sparked passionate debate, but all that has a chance of coming to an end. The Supreme Court is going to judge a case of a trans student, Gavin Grimm, who was forced by a Virginia school to use an “alternative private” restroom. If the Court rules that this requirement is indeed unconstitutional, this could vastly reduce transphobic discrimination throughout the country. Bills like HB2 in North Carolina could be seen as violating the same rules and be knocked down easily. While it wouldn’t be the end of transphobia, it would be a huge step forward on the path to equality: a ruling that public accommodations need to be accessible to trans people would lay the groundwork for more rulings that prevent discrimination on the basis of gender alignment.

That’s all if the Supreme Court does rule that transphobic bathroom discrimination in schools is unconstitutional.

A few weeks ago, this result seemed inevitable to me. Just the fact that the Supreme Court would hear the case seemed to mean the ruling had already been decided. I assumed this would be obvious, and there was no chance of an alternate ruling.

Now that Trump won the presidency, these chances are very different. A conservative justice replacing Scalia could mean the Supreme Court will tilt right, and it could rule that this discrimination is constitutional. This would be disastrous for trans rights. It would set the movement back years. We can’t let this happen. Of course, this all depends on who Trump nominates for the position and whether the Senate confirms a transphobic justice who will rule against equality.

The Supreme Court is expected to hear the case sometime in 2017.

1
2
Leave a Comment
Donate to The Pitch
$775
$1000
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation will support the student journalists of Walter Johnson High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

More to Discover
About the Contributor
Yael Hanadari-Levy, Editor In Chief
This is senior Yael Hanadari-Levy’s second year working on the Pitch and first year as editor-in-chief. She doesn’t have any free time between school, her internship and the Pitch, but if she did she would probably spend it writing. Yael is an officer in the GSA and the WJ She’s The First chapter, and is a member of Feminism Club.
Donate to The Pitch
$775
$1000
Contributed
Our Goal

Comments (0)

All The Pitch Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *